Monday, August 18, 2008

Information Technology Risk Issues Facing US Companies Seeking Global Expansion

Rewards and risks surround any organization considering the notion of going global, and identifying the potential risks of expansion can be challenging. One area that is often overlooked is that of information technology (IT) risk (Goodwill, 2006). The purpose of this essay is to discuss how the explosion of information technology and the incredible advances in global communications pose significant risks to American global organizations as they expand in the international environment. This essay examines four areas of IT risk: ineffective or nonexistent IT risk management programs, supply chain fraud, technology risk associated with entering into a joint venture (JV) and foreign protectionism practices. Each issue is discussed, as well as potential solutions to mitigate risk.

Poor IT Risk Management Programs

Lack of (effective) established IT risk management programs, especially in the financial services sector, creates an inherent risk in that it exposes data that is supposed to be privy and confidential. Ernst & Young issued a report in February, 2008 indicating that 22 percent of companies surveyed with assets over $10 billion have no formal IT risk management program, and that more than 40 percent of executives (Curtis, 2008) “did not feel their firm was effective in risk reporting and disclosure, risk and issues management, and trend analysis” (Curtis, 2008, par. 2). The issue of IT risk management is overlooked, as most companies focus on political, economic, environmental and regulatory risks (Curtis, 2008).

Supply Chain Fraud

Supply chain fraud is an issue that is currently on the rise (Anonymous, 2008), especially among international shippers (Hoffman, 2008). According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation supply chain fraud is costing US shippers an estimated $15 billion to $30 billion annually (Hoffman, 2008). “Vulnerabilities for companies increase as they expand and globalize, add new information-technology systems, and as their supply chains become more extended and complex” (Anonymous, 2008, par. 2). Also, “[s]ince it is relatively cheap and easy to store information electronically, companies are holding on to data (and) information longer, which increases risks for fraud due to the increased volume" (Demichelis, cited in Hoffman, 2008, par. 2). Lastly, the supply chain is open to fraud “because of global growth and increased outsourcing, according to a recent Global Fraud Report released by Kroll, the New York-based risk consulting firm” (Yoo-chul, 2008, par. 3). Most of the incidents of fraud are considered to be carried on from the inside (Hoffman, 2008).

Joint Ventures

Entering into a JV is an inherently risky decision, as A JV, in essence, is a partnership between two or more entities. Partnerships do have a high degree of risk due to joint and several liability of the entity’s owners, which is why many international JVs fail (Borgonjon & Hoffman, 2008). “Nearly 30 years of experience has taught foreign investors that, when possible, it is better to go it alone” (Borgonjon & Hoffman, 2008, par. 3). This is not to say that JVs aren’t attractive in certain markets, though. The easiest way to enter the Chinese market and share in the rewards (i.e., increased profitability, higher market share, and exploitation of technology) is via JV (Collins, 2007; Borgonjon & Hoffman, 2008). The disadvantage to sharing technology is that existing intellectual property is difficult to protect once it is shared by the JV, especially in China (Collins, 2007).

Technological Protectionism

US firms attempting to expand into other areas of the world may encounter practices of protectionism, which are designed to restrict foreign trade (Gupta & Govindarajan, 2004). Protectionism of technology occurs when a country establishes its own unique technical standards for the purposes of shutting out foreign competition (China Post, 2008). This puts US based and other companies at an unfair disadvantage. “Many American companies have expressed concern about security standards for information technology products that made it costly for them to enter the Chinese market” (Padilla, cited in China Post, 2008). JapanChina is using this method of protectionism to provide its companies with a competitive advantage (China Post, 2008). attempted this practice in the 1980s, and it failed (China Post, 2008). Currently,

Combating IT Risk

In terms of IT risk management programs, it is important to first have an effective system of internal controls in place. An established, written system of checks and balances is a good start to mitigating risk (Robbins & Coultier, 2007), but it is not enough to have written policies and procedures. Internal controls must be carried through and enforced from the top down (Kinney, 2000), and management must refrain from overriding controls (Horngren, Harrison, & Bamber, 2006)

Also, the design of the IT Risk management system should be carefully considered.

The problem with many IT risk management programs that leads to their ineffectiveness is the fact that most large companies place risk in the various silos of the organization. Many international organizations are designed to have multiple lines of business, each with its own IT systems. Even though the processes from multiple silos overlap – due to common processes and services – there is no common, binding understanding and/or assessment of the IT risks involved in the organization as a whole. The need for convergence – or at minimum integrated risk management - exists (Curtis, 2008).

The problem with converging systems is the fact that most risk management solutions vendors and software packages are designed for specific aspects of the organization: there is no blanket package yet available to facilitate an integrated approach (Curtis, 2008; Goodwill, 2006). However, the push towards a more holistic approach to IT risk management is starting to be met by market demands:

“There is a movement toward automating the risk management process to make it lower in cost and more efficient… The tools supporting risk management are evolving and becoming more integrated. This is where we see opportunity, [in part] by implementing acommon risk language to roll up and report risk to an organization (Barrett, cited in Curtis, 2008, par. 16).

The holistic approach can be a viable solution to other areas of IT risk, such as supply chain fraud. “[S]hippers and service providers invest heavily in security guards, fences, access controls and locks” (Hoffman, 2008, par. 6), but a level of internal controls deemed adequate from a textbook approach is not enough to deter fraud. The human element is being ignored (Hoffman, 2008). Chains, locks, and a well-documented system of internal controls is sufficient to be in compliance with “Customs-Trade Partnership Against Terrorism and Transported Assets Protection Association security programs” (Hoffman, 2008, par. 7), but the controls will not prevent “a part-time warehouse worker

with temporary access codes who knows when the high-value cargo is leaving” (Hoffman, 2008, par. 7) from engaging in fraudulent activity.

“The lesson is that you really have to approach protecting your business and supply chain with a very holistic approach… There has to be some actual human element to try to beat those systems once you're compliant. There is no silver bullet (Hoffman, 2008, par. 8).

The holistic approach can also work well when deciding whether to do business in China, but it should be in used in conjunction with every effort to carefully and properly plan expansion. Any US company seeking to expand into the Chinese market should consider placing tight controls over the supply chain management, constantly monitoring and reviewing quality control programs, as well as finding the right company to do business with (Canning, 2008).

“U.S. companies looking to do business with China, therefore, would be wise to adopt the famous Boy Scout motto: ‘Be Prepared.’ Armed with the right information and resources, they will be able to reap financial and other rewards from relationships with respectable Chinese manufacturers. To ensure the highest quality and safety of the private label end products, Bi [sourcing specialist in China] recommends that companies thoroughly research the industry to identify highly qualified manufacturers. An expert who’s bilingual in English and Chinese is critical to this effort and should be involved from the very beginning. After the deal is authorized, the U.S. buyer should put someone in place to monitor the production on a continuous basis” (Canning, 2008, par 20-22).

Companies that do not have the resources necessary to effectively set up operations in China should seek a sourcing agent who can assist the U.S. organization in finding reputable companies to do business with (Canning, 2008). Much like finding the right business partner, employee, or investor, the U.S. company seeking to go into a JV with a Chinese firm should find someone who can be trusted. Despite China’s reputation, a perfect marriage in business can be attained (Cunningham, Cunningham, and Park, 2008).

Careful consideration should also be taken when dealing with China’s stance on technological protectionism. When faced with this issue, U.S. companies wishing to do business with the Chinese have three options:

Invest the necessary resources to effectively enter the Chinese market.

Postpone the decision to do business in China until the short-term effects of protectionism are short lived.

Consider entering into another country.

Summary

This essay discusses how the explosion of information technology and the incredible advances in global communications pose significant risks to American global organizations as they expand in the international environment by examining four areas of IT risk: ineffective or nonexistent IT risk management programs, supply chain fraud, technology risk associated with entering into a joint venture (JV) and foreign protectionism practices. Textbook solutions and hasty decisions are not adequate to hedge IT-related risks. Rather, careful planning and a holistic approach are favored.


Anonymous (May 12, 208). Report: supply chains are at greater risk for fraud. Shipping Digest, 85 (4446). Retrieved May 24, 2008 from the EBSCOHost database.

Canning, K. (April, 2008). Risky business. Private Label Buyer, 24 (11). Retrieved May 24, 2008 from the EBSCOHost database.

China Post. (May 10, 2008). U.S. warns China of technological isolation. China Post. Retrieved May 24, 2008 from the EBSCOHost database.

Collins, M. (December, 2007). Outsourcing: the good, the bad, and the ugly. Industrial Maintenance & Plant Operation, 68(12). Retrieved March 3, 2008 from the EBSCOhost database.

Cunningham, M. G., Cunningham, D. B. & Park, D. (March 2008). Reflections on doing business in China: a case study. International Journal of Management, 25 (1). Retrieved May 24, 2008 from the EBSCOHost database.

Curtis, C. E. (March 17, 2008). Emphasis on IT risk management driving new solutions. Securities Industries News, 20(11). Retrieved May 24, 2008 from the EBSCOHost database.

Goodwill, B. May 16, 2006). Get IT integrated for risk management, bosses told. Computer Weekly, 00104787. Retrieved May 24, 2008 from the EBSCOHost database.

Grosse, R. E. (2000). Thunderbird on global business strategy. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Gupta, A. K., & Govindarajan, V. (2004). Global Strategy and Organization. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Hoffman, W. (May 12, 2008). Fighting supply chain fraud. Traffic World, 272 (19). Retrieved May 24, 2008 from the EBSCOHost database.

Horngren, C. T., Harrison, W, & Bamber, L. Accounting. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 2006.

Kinney. W. R. Information Quality Assurance and Internal Control for Management Decision Making. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2000.

Koremans, S. (October 19, 2007). Outsourcing: how to make it work. B&T Weekly, 57(2633). Retrieved March 3, 2008 from the EBSCOhost database.

Robbins, S.P. & Coulter (2007). Management, (9th ed.). Pearson: Upper Saddle River, NJ.

Schultz, R. A. (2006). Contemporary issues in ethics and information technology. Hershey, PA: Idea Group, Inc.

Yoo-chul, K. (May 5, 2008). Supply chain fraud top concern for firms. World News Connection. Retrieved May 24, 2008 from the EBSCOHost database.

Are American Female Executives a Risk Factor in the Global Economy?

In order for an organization to effectively manage risk, executive management must examine all potential factors that may have an impact on its ability to achieve goals, satisfy shareholders, and – among other aspects – maintain a positive perceived image among its supply chain. One of the pivotal areas of interest and risk is the manner with which American global organizations perceive their female executives in global roles. In an increasingly-interlinked world, organizational/employee constituencies will be made up of female executives, especially within management cadres (given the numerical growth of women in the domestic workforce). The purpose of this paper is to address the possible issues inherent in this shift. More specifically, the risk of assigning female staff persons to pivotal roles in an organization’s global effort and where exactly the female executive fits in the global endeavor, considering that sometimes perceptions found in the global environment may pose risk to the potential success of an organization, will be discussed. First, the issue of risk management is presented and areas of risk management are discussed, followed by a presentation of potential risks associated with female executives in the global business world. In addition, the person(s) who might be in the organization’s charge becomes extraordinarily important and redolent with risk will be identified. Finally, an assessment on the risks of placing female executives in global companies and the issue of organizational fit, as described above, will be presented.

A risk management assessment from a global approach should be taken from more angles than a U.S. organization that operates solely on a domestic level. First, a company that conducts its business on a domestic level can obtain its information easier than one that wishes to expand its operations into new soil. For example, should a local firm decide to expand its operations into different areas of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania the management of the company would already be familiar with the laws and regulations of the Commonwealth, so the task is less daunting. Much more research is needed prior to entry into the global market. A company wishing to expand its operations into a different domestic region may not need to be as concerned with establishing relationships with the region’s existing business leaders, members of local communities, and government officials as a firm would if it were to expand globally to alleviate concerns of the region (Gupta & Govindarajan, 2004). Companies wanting to enter the global market must launch a public relations campaign to help gain the foreign public’s trust and respect while maintaining relations with the local communities and government. Opting-in to create a global posture is not always the best strategy. The culture of the foreign region, people, and business and political leaders whom management will form a relationship with may advise otherwise. The inclusion of female executives into the mix of management may also yield a potential risk.

One of the pivotal areas of interest and risk is the manner with which American global organizations perceive their female executives in global roles. American, as well as British, firms find women executives to be an asset in the global economy, especially in terms of preaching diversity (Streel & White, 2003). Cultural differences between the two nations may indicate potential risk factors, though. American women executives and those trying to climb the corporate ladder tend to have more ambition than those from the U.K. and can be perceived as overbearing – or manly – in some cultures (Emling, 2004). In some countries, the inability for a woman – regardless of beaurocratic level – to act feminine may indeed be a risk factor one not considered by American women. The perception of sending a woman to do a man’s job may seem offensive to foreign executives, although female managers and executives are commonly accepted in the U.S. In short, foreign executives may not feel comfortable dealing with women while conducting business (Fingar, 2001). “Europe is not… ready to embrace the unconflicted businesswoman. A survey of European directors shows that stereotypes of women's abilities and a lack of female role models are among the top barriers to advancement.” (Foroohar & Radcliffe, 2003, par. 11).

Domestic companies have taken strides in breaking the glass ceiling in the United States, but the global business world is still perceived to be a man’s world (Fingar, 2001). U.S. companies are giving women opportunities they may not have otherwise had 50 years ago, as indicated by a study conducted by “Catalyst, a New York-based research firm that studies workplace issues that affect women” (Fingar, 2001, par. 2), noting that “women now represent nearly half of the U.S. managerial labor pool” (Fingar, 2001, par. 3). U.S. companies are still cautious about sending women overseas due to the global perception that the international business world is still a man’s world. Women are willing to take on global assignments, but the apparent risks associated with sending women and lack of acceptance in the global business community need to be addressed. Currently, the risk containment strategy used by domestic organizations is to keep women moving up the corporate ladder in the U.S. and limiting their exposure abroad. This tactic, however, has a major drawback: more large companies are requiring that executive and high level management positions be filled with people who have some global experience (Fingar, 2001). Failure to provide women the opportunity to participate in the global environment can lead to backlash, leaving existing corporate directors and executives in a quandary.

Acceptance and American attitude in the foreign board room, particularly with women executives, are the result of perception and cultural differences. In parts of the world, where women are not accepted in leadership, such as the Middle East, sending a female executive to conduct business may give the domestic company the perception that it is weak or not serious about doing business. The culture and government of the United States have taken great strides in giving women the opportunity to be placed in leadership roles and break into the global economy. The rest of the world, however, may not be as ready. Even though companies in the U.K., New Zealand, Germany, and other countries are bringing women into the boardroom, they are still far behind the times when compared to U.S. companies (Jellnek & Adler, 1988; Fingar, 2001; & Emiling, 2004).

Risk containment by allowing only a small percentage of women in foreign board rooms is not a permanent solution. The problem lies in how the global business environment can be changed to accept women as equals. Organizations in developed countries have either implemented or are in the process of implementing programs to train women to become global executives (Fingar, 2001), but these training programs do not solve the issue of fostering an environment where women can succeed in every corner of the world: cultural barriers will remain. Breaking down these glass walls is a daunting task and leads to additional questions:

Should existing executives take a more proactive role in changing the attitudes and/or perceptions of individuals in lesser developed countries to accept women executives in the board room?

Would government intervention via international relations tools, tariffs, and incentives create a more level playing field?

Should domestic companies soften women executives to become more accepted in foreign board rooms?

Is the only solution to be patient and allow ample time for other countries’ cultures to become more tolerant and acceptable of women leaders?

The answers to these questions on how the environment should be changed and who should be responsible for making changes are outside the scope of this report and may become considered as the bases for additional studies. This report aimed to examine the possible issues inherent in bringing female executives to the forefront of international business. The risk of assigning female staff persons to pivotal roles in an organization’s global effort and where exactly the female executive fits in the global endeavor, considering that sometimes perceptions found in the global environment may pose risk to the potential success of an organization, were discussed. First, the issue of risk management was presented and areas of risk management were discussed, followed by a presentation of potential risks associated with female executives in the global business world. It was noted that acceptance and American attitude in the foreign board room, particularly with women executives, are the result of perception and cultural differences and that the only solution provided by American companies for risk containment is to limit the number of women executives overseas. The global environment needs to change before more women executives can be brought onto the international scene.


References

De Streel, M. & White, E. (2003, May 7). Burberry CEO delivers an encore to top list of women executives. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved May 13, 2008 from http://www.marcusventures.com/press/wsjwomen.htm.

Fingar, C. (2001, January). Stay-at-home careers? Export Today''s Global Business, 17(1), 62.

Foroohar, R. & Radcliffe, L. (2003, November 17). Unless you're queen. Newsweek, 142(20), E28.

Gupta, A. K., & Govindarajan, V. (2004). Global Strategy and Organization. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Jellnek, M. & Adler, N. J. (1988, February). Women: World-class managers for global competition. Academy of Management Executive, 2(1), 11.

How Ethics and the U.S. Government Increase Global Risk for American Companies

Much like a small business expanding its operations, a domestic organization seeking to enter the global market should be aware of the risks associated with spreading out into different corners of the world. A thorough analysis of the financial, market, political, and other risks should be conducted before deciding to enter the global arena (Gupta & Govindarajan, 2004). When conducting a risk assessment, the issue of ethics should be examined, as ethical differences between cultures and the decision to enter the global market can lead to ethical implications. The purpose of this paper is to analyze how ethics (or lack thereof) creates significant risk for American global business endeavors. More specifically, this essay focuses on the risks American businesses face by outsourcing manufacturing to Southeast Asia and attempting to enter into contracts where bribery is an accepted form of practice. Each of these trends is discussed in detail, followed by an assessment on the risks a U.S. company may face by choosing to participate in the global economy in these manners. A discussion on how the existing U.S. federal legal and regulatory environment contributes to increasing the risks that domestic firms face when attempting to enter the global arena is also presented.

Outsourcing manufacturing to Southeast Asia

In an effort to increase profitability, U.S. firms are outsourcing their manufacturing operations to companies in Asia, where manufacturing costs are significantly lower than in the United States (Schwartz & Gibb, 1999). The latest major U.S. manufacture to announce plans to outsource manufacturing to the Pacific region is Pfizer, Inc., which plans to outsource up to 30% of its production (Associated Press, 2007). Other U.S. based companies that have already decided to outsource their manufacturing to Southeast Asian firms have seen the benefits of doing so, including Mattel, Nike, and Philips (Knight Ridder, 2006).

Aside from cost savings and improving the bottom line, outsourcing blue collar jobs can also allow a company to operate around the clock without incurring overtime costs (Koremans, 2007). Outsourcing to foreign countries has its list of disadvantages as well. Approximately 50% of outsourcing operations are estimated to fall below expectations (Collins, 2007). There are also “branding, regulatory, social, geopolitical, human capital and legal risks that companies may not anticipate” (Collins, 2007, par. 7) which can end up costing the organization greatly (Collins, 2007). American companies can also face problems defending intellectual property rights once they enter the Asian arena:

“Intellectual property is a big issue when dealing with China and in the Asian Pacific region in general. Copying, reverse engineering and even counterfeiting products is not an unusual business practice in these countries. It is now obvious to most U.S. companies that the Asian view of business ethics is much different than the U.S. view of business ethics. Even a signed contract may be no protection (Collins, 2007, par. 8).

Lastly, there is the issue of poor quality. In 2007, China was subject to embarrassment, and companies who rely on Chinese manufacturers began to see the financial risk of relying on substandard quality. News about lethal petfood, lead paint in children’s toys and poor quality tires gave China a bad reputation (Hilton, 2008), which lead to a fall in consumer confidence with companies who did not manufacture their toys within the country.

The use of bribery to land contracts.

Outsourcing manufacturing is just one way a company can break into the global economy. Organizations specializing in engineering, consulting, or construction find themselves biding on overseas projects. U.S. firms engaging in this activity are not as successful as those in other countries due to existing regulations, primarily the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) which makes it illegal for a U.S. firm doing business outside of the United States to use any form of bribery to influence business.

“Bribery alone is causing U.S. firms to lose billions of dollars in overseas contracts. Since 1994, the U.S. government has learned of almost 100 cases of foreign firms using bribery to undercut U.S. firms' efforts to win international contracts worth about $45 billion. The foreign firms that offer bribes typically win about 80 percent of the deals” (Anonymous, 1996, par. 4).

Inability to bribe due to the constraints of the FCPA makes it difficult to compete with other countries where bribery is not only accepted, it is also an allowable expense on the foreign firms’ financial statements (Anonymous, 1996). This leaves U.S. firms at a disadvantage in terms of auditing standards. Should a domestic company decide to engage in such practices it would be required to report the activity in its financial statements, either on the income statement or as a supplemental note to the financial statements, as required under the disclosure principal (Horngren, Harrison, & Bamber, 2006).

Other countries bidding for these projects employ aggressive tactics to attract foreign business and contracts. For example, France

”uses government lobbying--such as phone calls, letters, and high-level visits--as well as generous Financing packages and trade shows to win market share in foreign countries. The French promote exports in all of the major growth sectors, especially high-technology projects such as high-speed trains, nuclear power plants, and telecommunications” (Anonymous, 1996, par. 6).

“United Kingdom… uses high-level visits more frequently than any other rival… Approximately one-fifth of British diplomats abroad are engaged full-time in commercial work, and London is expanding the provision of favorable financing through its Export Credit Guarantee division. The United Kingdom has also developed strategic initiatives that target geographic areas, including its "North America Now," "Priority Japan," and "Know-How Fund" (focusing on Central Europe) programs” (Anonymous, 1996, par. 7)

Germany also uses the tactic of frequent high-level visits (Anonymous, 1996) “with particular emphasis on infrastructure and machinery. Economic Minister Rexrodt stated that promoting exports will be at "the very top of the priority list" of the German government and that all politicians must actively support German enterprises in expanding their markets” (Anonymous, 1996, par. 8).

While a firm is not expected to earn every contract bid upon, a 20% success rate among all U.S. based companies is low, indicating that the risks involved in bidding are high in terms of the time and effort spent developing blueprints and the actual bid itself. The risk of failure to obtain the bid and the risk of loss of time and money invested in preparing the contract are high.

Existing legislative environment

The U.S. federal government has played an active role in encouraging major domestic corporations to enter the global economy, specifically countries that practice protectionism, by way of trade agreements (Gupta & Govindarajan, 2004) and tax incentives (anonymous, 2000). At the same time, the federal government failed to enact its own level of protectionisms to protect its people and American jobs. Faulty tires, lethal dogfood, and lead-tainted toys have been allowed to enter the country in support of global trade and for the sake of lowering a trade deficit. Business ethics between U.S. firms and those in developing countries are often not on the same level, and, while most U.S. companies have taken matters into their own hands, there are still a number of companies that continue to allow harmful, defective products to reach into the hands of the American consumer. When U.S. businesses fail to push for ethics reform, it then becomes the responsibility of the federal government to enact appropriate regulation. Lack of appropriate government involvement in this matter has been a contributing factor. The U.S.U.S. companies to compete more effectively in the global marketplace. Lastly, the U.S. government failed to create its own laws of protectionism to deal with a growing base of displaced American workers. government is also a contributing factor to the failure of domestic firms’ bidding by enforcing the FCPA and not amending it to allow

Summary

The purpose of this paper was to analyze how ethics (or lack thereof) creates significant risk for American global business endeavors. More specifically, this essay focused on the risks American businesses face by outsourcing manufacturing to Southeast Asia and attempting to enter into contracts where bribery is an accepted form of practice.

U.S. companies who wish to take advantage of lower manufacturing costs in Southeast Asia as well as other parts of the world must be aware that there are risks involved that may outweigh the improved bottom line. There are socio-political regulatory, and geographic, factors to consider. Also, as with any decision to outsource, the issue of controlling quality of the product must be considered. As was witnessed in the fall of 2007, consumer confidence fell with companies who outsourced their manufacturing operations to China and brought back substandard products. Organizations bidding on overseas projects step onto an uneven playing field. They cannot compete effectively due to the FCPA, which prohibits bribery.

The U.S. federal government failed to enact its own doctrine of protectionism to safeguard its people and American jobs and repeatedly failed to appropriately regulate domestic companies doing business overseas. The U.S. government is also a contributing factor to the failure of domestic firms’ bidding by enforcing the FCPA and not amending it to allow U.S. companies to compete more effectively in the global marketplace. Perhaps changing regulations to punish corporations that are doing the wrong thing may enforce companies to employ a standardized level of conduct across their respective corners of the globe.
References

Anonymous. (1996, October). Foreign practices. Across the Board, 33(9), 11-12.

Anonymous. (2000, December 16). Finance and economics: Going too far in support of trade. The Economist, 357(8201), 88.

Associated Press (December 1, 2007). Pfizer considers outsourcing manufacturing to Asia. The Grand Rapids Press. Retrieved March 3, 2008 from the ProQuest database.

Collins, M. (December, 2007). Outsourcing: the good, the bad, and the ugly. Industrial Maintenance & Plant Operation, 68(12). Retrieved March 3, 2008 from the EBSCOhost database.

Gibb, B., & Schwartz, P. (1999). When good companies do bad things: Responsibility & risk in an age of globalization. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Gupta, A. K., & Govindarajan, V. (2004). Global Strategy and Organization. New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Hilton, I. (February, 2008). When bad news is good news. Ecologist, 38(1). Retrieved March 3, 2008 from the EBSCOhost database.

Horngren, C. T., Harrison, W, & Bamber, L. Accounting. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 2006.

Knight Ridder (September 18, 2006). Philips to consolidate HQ in NCR by ’08. Knight Ridder Tribune Business News. Retrieved March 3, 2008 from the ProQuest database.

Koremans, S. (October 19, 2007). Outsourcing: how to make it work. B&T Weekly, 57(2633). Retrieved March 3, 2008 from the EBSCOhost database.

Nike - just do it?

Swiderski & Associates, LLC is a small accounting firm consisting of five professionals from northeastern Pennsylvania. Its owner, Paul Swiderski (hereinafter referred to as the “subject”), considers himself to be an ethical leader and stresses making ethical decisions within the enterprise. In a previous report, the subject’s personal approach to a business ethical decision was transformed into an ethical leadership decision making plan/model from which his employees can draw upon when faced with a business ethics issue.

The purpose of this essay is to apply this model to a current global business situation. More specifically, this report examines the ethical decision making process as it applies to Nike’s child labor practices in Southeast Asia. First, the issue of Nike’s child labor practices is discussed, followed by an application of the ethical decision making process to analyze and make recommendations for leadership action.

About Nike

“Nike is the largest seller of athletic footwear and apparel in the world. The company is primarily engaged in the design, development, and worldwide marketing of footwear, apparel, equipment, and accessories. The company operates in the US, Europe, Asia Pacific, the Middle East and Africa. It is headquartered in Beaverton, Oregon” (Marketline, 2007, par. 1). In 1996, Nike was accused of allowing unfair labor practices in Southeast Asia, including the employment of unethical child labor practices (Jenkins, 2003). More information is presented in the following sections.

Child Labor Practices in Southeast Asia

In the 1990’s, activist groups and charities focused their attention on unfair labor practices in Southeast Asia, including child labor violations (Jenkins, 2003, Zadek, 2004). These groups targeted Nike because of its high-profile brand, not because its business practices were any worse than its competitors' “(Zadek, 2004, par. 16). Nike’s initial reaction was to counter “with public statements showing that it required all contractors to sign, abide by and document compliance with a Memorandum of Understanding that commits its contractors to follow all local laws about wages, benefits, child labor, equal opportunity, working conditions, etc.” (Jenkins, 2003, par. 9).

When Nike’s initial attempts to counter public statements with their own failed, the company hired firms to conduct independent investigations into the issue. However, the firms retained by Nike were either unqualified or lacked appropriate credibility (Jenkins, 2003, Zadek, 2004). “In 1997, the company asked Andrew Young, a U.S. civil rights leader and former United Nations ambassador, to carry out an independent audit of Nike contractors' labor practices. Young examined 12 factories and reported favorably for Nike, finding no evidence of widespread abuse or mistreatment, but did comment that Nike could do better” (Jenkins, 2003, par. 10). Pressure from activist groups continued (Jenkins, 2003, Zadek, 2004).

Finally, Nike became proactive in this matter by “creating its first department specifically responsible for managing its supply chain partners' compliance with labor standards. And in 1998, Nike established a Corporate Responsibility department, acknowledging that acting responsibly was far more than just reaching compliance; it was an aspect of the business that had to be managed like any other”(Zadek, 2004, par. 17).

Business Discipline

There are two dominant disciplines involved in this case: corporate social responsibility, and supply chain management. Both are intermingled in with international business theories.

Decisions to Be Made

Nike had to make a clear decision to alleviate pressure from activist groups. When public statements and appeasement (by way of independent investigations) fail, Nike’s executives were required to think of a different way to truly solve the issue from a long-term perspective.

International Regulations

This case deals with child labor; however, no standardized international code of child labor laws exists. Nike would have to resort to complying with the labor laws of the individual foreign countries in which it operates and/or supply chain members reside.

Potential Issues Involving Disparate Legal Systems and Practices

The following questions/issues arise:

Can a company establish and enforce policies on supply chain members?

Should the company use the host country’s or supply chain member’s, or develop a higher, standardized policy for all supply chain members to follow?


Application of Critical Thinking Approach

Revised business ethics decision model for Swiderski & Associates, LLC

I.

Gather the facts and determine what the issue is. Ask questions if necessary.

II.

Identify all possible solutions to the issue/problem.

III.

Examine each solution and identify:

A.

Applicable laws/regulations, if any

B.

Interpretation of existing laws/regulations, if identified in A, above

C.

Legal reasoning

D.

Legal ramifications, if any

E.

Consistency in application

F.

Appropriateness

G.

Long-term ramifications for client and firm

H.

Ethical norms

I.

Advantages

J.

Disadvantages

K.

Audit Risk

IV.

Select solutions and discuss options with client.

The predominant issue, based on the facts presented, is that Nike’s supply chain members violated child labor laws. As a result of these findings, activist groups and non-profit organizations pressured Nike to make changes by using the press as their medium. In such cases, there are three solutions: ignore the issue (or do little outside issue press releases); hire independent investigators to validate data; or engage leadership to take a proactive approach in dealing with the issue. The first two options have proven to fail, while the third option lead to more positive results for the company over the long-run.


References

Jenkins, A. (April/May, 2003). What would you do. Communication World, 20(3). Retrieved September 5, 1007 from the EBSCOHost database.

Marketline (2007). Nike [company information]. Retrieved September 5, 2007 from the Marketline database.

Zadek, S. (December, 2004). The Path to Corporate Responsibility. Harvard Business Review, 82(2). Retrieved September 5, 1007 from the EBSCOHost database.

Organization Behavior Analysis of an Acquisition

In the midst of the multitude scandals of corporate corruption around the turn of the century, including those of Enron’s accounting fraud, Halliburton’s overcharging of government contracts, and the Compass Group’s bribery of the United Nations to win business (Corporate scandal, 2006), there have been a variety of financial ramifications. On one end of this spectrum, organizations ceased operations, while others have become bait for acquisition.

In this essay, the organizational behavior (OB) strategy related to the buyout of Adelphia Communications Corporation is examined. Included in the discussion is the evaluation of the overall organizational design approach, an assessment of the short and long term effectiveness of the design strategy, the anticipated internal and external environmental, political, sociological, psychological, and fiscal changes (positive and negative), and the anticipated impact of change on the business’ organizational behavior and structure. Recommendations for a future business of this nature will also be made.

Company Background

Adelphia Communications Corporation, founded in 1952, provides a variety of services under the umbrella of telecommunications, including cable television, high speed Internet, and media services, to over 5 million customers in over 30 states and Puerto Rico. Adelphia filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in 2002, after it became known that “John Rigas and his family [then majority shareholders]… fraudulently used the company's funds for personal loans, manipulated financial figures to conform with analysts' expectations, funded non-corporate projects using Adelphia's line-of-credit for personal purchases, creation of fictitious companies and sham transactions for inflating the company's earnings and concealed increasing debts” (Adelphia Communications Corporation, 2006, par 34). The organization filed five restructuring plans with the bankruptcy court, with its most recent amendment in August, 2006 (Adelphia Files Fifth Amended Plan of Reorganization and Related Disclosure Statement Supplement, 2006). On July 31, 2006, the entity announced that it closed a deal on July 31, 2006 with Comcast and Time Warner Cable (Adelphia Closes Asset Sale to Time Warner Cable and Comcast, 2006) to sell its assets for $12.7 billion (Adelphia Communications Corporation, 2006, par. 16).

Organizational behavior strategy evaluation

Current OB strategy

Now that the acquisition deal is closed, and Adelphia has been sold to Time Warner Cable and Comcast, the post-transactional transition begins. Much needs to be thought of during this period of time, including infrastructure, technology integration, and the decision as to whether retain Adelphia employees. To ease the transition from the closing of the deal to actual implementation of the buyout, teams were established by representatives of each involved party.

It is estimated that close to 13,000 Adelphia employees will be transferred to the buying companies (Adelphia Closes Asset Sale to Time Warner Cable and Comcast, 2006). No specifics can be found as to which jobs or job types will be sustained. The former Adelphia employees will need to be introduced to a new way of doing things, and it is presumed that Time Warner Cable and Comcast will conduct some form of orientation for the newly acquired human resources.

Strategy Assessment

Organizational Design

Being in the same industry, the buyers and the seller have similar organizational structures. The current organizational design for both Time Warner Cable and Comcast is that of a traditional bureaucracy as defined by Weber, comprised of executive leadership who fill well defined roles (cmcsk.com). The same can be said of the former Adelphia. Weber spoke about a rational-legal authority, and positions based upon merit of individuals; thus, Weber clearly distinguished a separation between the person, who may enter and leave a position, versus the position, who’s function remains in the bureaucracy (Jones, G. R., 2004). Because the companies are structured similar to each other, the transition from Adelphia to the buying companies’ structures should be relatively smooth as far as becoming accustomed to the human resource infrastructure, with the only short-term setback being the orientation of the former Adelphia employees to new policies and procedures. Upon successful hurdle of the learning curve, these employees should become accustomed to the changes and new environment. At the same time, though, management of the acquiring companies must work on maintaining a satisfactory level of retention among the Adelphia employees, as job security becomes a lingering thought among newly acquired employees.

The key difference between Adelphia and its acquirers is that the latter never entered the Voice Over IP telephone service market, which proved to be profitable for Comcast and Time Warner (Adelphia Buyout Boosts Cable in Bundling War with Satellite and Telcos; Acquisition Will Spur Cable VOIP Availability and Adoption, 2006). This could pose training challenges for the former Adelphia employees in the areas of training and technical competency. A successful training program, through mentoring and/or formal training, should ensure a knowledgeable staff among former Adelphia employees over the long run.

One key area to examine is that of the customer service personnel and technical training personnel, as the former Adelphia had a “poor record for retaining customers” (Adelphia Buyout Boosts Cable in Bundling War with Satellite and Telcos; Acquisition Will Spur Cable VOIP Availability and Adoption, 2006, par. 1). The length of time it takes for Adelphia emploees to improve on their retention is dependent on several factors, including the strength of the training programs and leadership capabilities of Comcast and Time Warner Cable, willingness of Adelphia employees to embrace change, and successful infusion of organizational philosophies.

Anticipated Changes in OB and Structure

The obvious change in the organizational structure of Adelphia deals with the fact that when transition is complete, the company will no longer exist. The structure of the company will transform from a traditional bureaucracy to nonexistence. Those human resources which will be transferred to Comcast or Time Warner Cable will still be employed, but by a different firm with similar organizational structure. Typical changes in employees when faced with an acquisition include job security and motivation.

Job security

Job security refers to being able to work within an organization for an indefinite period without worrying about being terminated. When some organizations are acquired, fewer positions are made available. Also some positions within the organization will be duplicated and many positions may be eliminated. This may cause various departments to downsize, in which employees may be moved around to other areas or possibly laid off of their jobs. The futures of the employees may become uncertain and many employees will become scared.

Motivation

Reinforcement theory argues that “reinforcement conditions behavior… Significant research indicates that people will exert more effort on tasks that are reinforced than on tasks that are not. Reinforcement is undoubtedly an important influence on work behavior. What people do on their jobs and the amount of effort they allocate to various tasks are affected by the consequences of their behavior” (Robbins, 2000, 115). By positively reinforcing model behavior and negatively reinforcing inappropriate workplace behavior through the use of feedback and other tools, managers can mold employees to increase performance, efficiency, and raise production. In order to improve on one’s performance, an individual must know where the areas of improvement lie. Robbins suggests that “[t]oo much information as well as too little can lay the foundation for conflict” (2000, p. 265) Hence, it is management’s responsibility to determine how much feedback is to be provided and whether to provide less feedback to those who wish to receive less. Alternately, management may wish to find out what other motivations theories may assist in motivating these two employees so as to not disturb the status quo, especially if the potential for conflict is considered high.

The Equity theory states “that employees weigh what they put into a job situation (input) against what they get from it (outcome) and then compare their input-outcome ratio with the input-outcome ratio of relevant others. If they perceive their ratio to be equal to that of the relevant others with whom they compare themselves, a state of equity is said to exist. They feel that their situation is fair, that justice prevails. If the ratios are unequal, inequity exists; that is, the employees tend to view themselves as under-rewarded or over-rewarded. When inequities occur, employees will attempt to correct them” (Robbins, 2000, p. 116).

The inequities can also be referred to as tension. The tension that is created usually affects employees in a number of ways. The under-rewarded employee has two options. First, their efforts may decrease resulting in lower productivity or poorer quality of out put, because they feel that they are not being paid adequately for the work they do. Secondly, the under-rewarded employee may produce a higher quantity of output, because they want to increase their equity or input. The latter statement is most important to this research. Although the under-rewarded employee is being paid less than his colleague for doing the same job, the tension that exists will make the employee change his work habits, thus motivating him to perform and possibly increasing his output. The same principle holds true for the over-rewarded employee. The over-rewarded employee will increase their output to justify the input side of the equation. This employee is motivated by the positive tension created by his inflated salary, thus the employee does not want to jeopardize losing his job or any portion of his salary, so he will consistently perform at a higher level of production. There are some unanswered questions in the equity theory, but researchers have proven that this theory has been used to motivate employees.

In the 1960’s, Victor Vroom developed the expectancy theory of motivation. It refers to the “the strength of a tendency to act in a certain way depends on the strength of an expectation that the act will be followed by a given outcome” and depending on how appealing the outcome is to the individual (Robbins, 2001). There are three variables of the expectancy theory. The possible reward that can be gained on the job is significant to the employee. This is known as attractiveness. Performance-reward linkage is the belief that performing on a certain level will allow the employee to gain a desirable outcome. When the employee believes that the more effort put forth leads to performance, this is referred as effort-performance linkage. According to Richard Scholl, a professor at the University of Rhode Island, there are three additional variables that affect the expectancy perception, self-efficacy, goal difficulty, and perceived control over performance (2002). Self-efficacy is the employee’s belief regarding his or her skills and goals required to perform in a satisfactory manner. In situations where the employee believes goals are set too high and the performance level is too difficult, expectancy perceptions and motivation become low. This is goal difficulty within an organization. Under the “perceived control over performance” theory, expectancy is high when the employee thinks they have some type of control over the outcome. If the employee perceives that he or she cannot control a given situation, motivation is low.

As management informs employees of their progress while working on a task within an organization, many become motivated if the progress is positive. If the progress is negative, it gives the employee a chance to discuss the situation with management and make an effort to improve before the task is complete. Scholl suggests that these types of individuals believe that they have control over the outcome; therefore expectancy is high within the organization. But when employees feel they have not control of the outcome of a situation, expectancy and motivation is low (2001).

In terms of this acquisition, it is important to note that Adelphia employees who do not receive enough communication, too much communication, or feel substandard when compared to Time Warner or Comcast employees may be less motivated in their new work environments.

Additional Analysis

Several questions remain including:

Did the organization conduct appropriate research in developing its organizational behavior strategy?

Did the organization effectively analyze environmental impacts?

At the time this essay was written, no data could be found to answer these questions. However, one can assume, based on the analysis written by Strategy Analytics, Inc. that the acquisition was well thought out and carefully planned by all three parties. Time will be a determining factor in determining the effectiveness of the acquiring companies’ research.

Implications and Recommendations for Further Analysis

As of the time that this essay was written, the acquisition has closed and the post-transactional phase of implementation began. Therefore, an analysis of the post-implementation period could not be conducted.

Upon successful transition, additional research should be conducted to determine the OBOB theory should be applied to determine if any theories will be applicable, whether they were properly incorporated, and whether theories were omitted. Second, an analysis should be conducted to determine how the use (or misuse) of design strategy and OB principles affected the implementation. Finally, an objective analysis should be conducted to determine whether any of the arguments and theories presented herein appear to be supported upon the outcome of the transition.
References
and design implications of the buyout. First, Swiderski’s taxonomy of

Adelphia (2006). Wikipedia. Retrieved June 20, 2006, from the World Wide Web: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adelphia.

Adelphia Closes Asset Sale to Time Warner Cable and Comcast (2006, July 31). Retrieved September 11, 2006 from the World Wide Web: http:// www.adelphia.com/pdf/Adelphia_Close_Release_FINAL.pdf.

Adelphia Communications Corporation (2006). Retrieved September 11, 2006 from the Datamonitor MarketLine Business Information Center.

Adelphia Files Fifth Amended Plan of Reorganization and Related Disclosure Statement Supplement (2006, August 18). Retrieved September 11, 2006 from the World Wide Web: http://www.adelphia.com/pdf/Adelphia_5th_Plan_Release.pdf.

Corporate scandal (2006) [list of recent corporate scandals], Wikipedia. Retrieved July 5, 2006 from the World Wide Web: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_abuse.

FCC to vote on Comcast, Times Warner’s Adelphia buy July 13 (2006, July 7) [Market Watch online]. Retrieved July 7, 2006, from the World Wide Web: http://www.marketwatch.com/News/Story/Story.aspx?dist=newsfinder&siteid=google&guid=%7BE04DE037-1D35-48C8-B4AD-A6CD6668EA6E%7D&keyword=

Form 8-K [Time Warner, Inc., filed April 21, 2005] (2005). Retrieved July 4, 2006 from the World Wide Web: http://www.shareholder.com/Common/Edgar/1105705/

1105705-05-33/05-00.pdf.

Jones, G. R. (2004). Organizational theory, design, and change (4th ed.). New York: Prentice-Hall, Inc. Downloaded from galenet.galegroup.com, on August 26, 2006.

Jung, H. (2002, June 24). Job security, pensions are top issues as Boeing talks begin. The Ledger-Enquirer.com. Retrieved August 5, 2002 from the World Wide Web: http://www.ledger-enquirer.com/mld/ledgerenquirer/business/3531396.html

Robbins, S. P. (2001). Organizational Behavior (9th ed.). Boston: Pearson Custom.

Scholl, R. (2002). Motivational processes – expectancy theory. University of Rhode Island – Classnotes. Retrieved August 12, 2002 from the World Wide Web: http://www.cba.uri.edu/scholl/notes/motivation_expectancy.html

Strategy Analytics, Inc. (2006). Adelphia Buyout Boosts Cable in Bundling War With Satellite, Telcos. Retreived September 11, 2006 from the World Wide Web: http://www.xchangemag.com/hotnews/68h41531.html.